(941) 241-7272
Sarasota • Manatee • Charlotte

How do cash home buyers calculate their offer?

Most work backward from what the house could sell for after repairs. Here is each piece of the math, a simple example, and how to check any offer, including ours. By Eric and Traci Bolen, November 9, 2026.

  • Cash offer, no obligation
  • No repairs, cleaning, or commissions
  • You pick the closing date

No pressure, ever. Your info stays private.

"How do cash home buyers come up with their offer?" is one of the first questions we get from homeowners around Sarasota, Bradenton, Venice, North Port, and Punta Gorda. It usually comes right after someone sees a number that is lower than their online estimate and wonders where the difference went. That is a fair thing to wonder. A number you cannot follow is a number you should not trust.

The short answer is that most cash buyers work backward. They start with what the house could sell for once it is fixed up, then subtract what it costs to get it there and resell it, plus a margin for their time and risk. What is left is the most they can pay. Below we walk through each piece in plain English, show a simple example with made-up numbers, and explain how to check any buyer's math, including ours.

We are Eric and Traci Bolen, a family-run company that buys houses for cash for our own account in Sarasota, Manatee, and Charlotte County, whether you want a cash offer for your North Port home or you are selling a house in Venice for cash. We would rather you understand the math and decide a cash offer is not for you than sign something you do not understand.

The basic formula

There is no law or industry standard that sets a cash offer. Every buyer runs their own numbers. But nearly all of them use some version of this:

Cash offer = after-repair value, minus repairs, minus buying and selling costs, minus holding costs, minus the buyer's margin.

Each of those pieces is an estimate, and each one can be checked. Here is what goes into them.

1. After-repair value

After-repair value, often shortened to ARV, is what the house would likely sell for on the open market if it were updated and move-in ready. It is not your online estimate, what you paid, or what your neighbor listed for. It comes from recent sales of comparable homes nearby that were in updated condition, adjusted for differences like square footage, bedrooms, lot, pool, and location.

Good comparables come from your own neighborhood when possible and from recent months. Here on the Gulf Coast, things like flood zone, elevation, roof age, and whether a home took on water in a storm can move value a lot between two houses that look similar on paper. A buyer who picks comparables from a nicer area, or from a different kind of house, will get a wrong starting number. That is why we show you the sales we used.

2. Repair costs

This is usually the biggest deduction and the one that varies most from house to house. It is the cost to bring the home from its current condition up to the condition behind the after-repair value. That can include:

  • Major systems: roof, air conditioning, electrical panel, plumbing, water heater.
  • Structure and moisture: foundation cracks, rot, mold, past water intrusion.
  • Interior: kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, paint, drywall.
  • Exterior: windows, doors, stucco, pool, landscaping, driveway.
  • Cleanout: furniture and belongings left behind, debris, pest treatment.

Two houses on the same street can get very different offers because one has a roof near the end of its life and the other does not. In Florida, roof age and condition also affect whether the next owner can get insurance, so it tends to matter more here than in some other places. If your house needs repairs or has storm or flood damage, this line will carry most of the weight in any cash offer you get.

3. Buying and selling costs

A cash buyer pays closing costs when they buy from you and again when they resell. On the resale side that often includes agent commissions, title insurance, documentary stamp taxes on the deed, and other closing charges. These costs are real and they come out of the same pool of money, so they are built into the offer up front. One of the trade-offs of a cash sale is that the buyer takes on these costs instead of you paying a commission on your own sale.

4. Holding costs

While the buyer owns the house during repairs and resale, they pay property taxes, insurance, utilities, HOA dues if there is an association, lawn care, and interest if they borrowed money for the project. The longer the work and the resale take, the more this adds up. A house that needs a permit for a new roof or a full remodel will usually carry more holding cost than one that needs paint and carpet.

5. The buyer's margin

Every buyer needs to make something for the money, time, and risk they put in. Repairs run over budget. Hidden problems show up behind walls. Markets shift between purchase and resale. The margin is the cushion for all of that, plus the buyer's actual profit. A buyer who is honest about having a margin is not being greedy. A buyer who pretends there is no margin is not being straight with you.

What about the "70% rule"?

You may see the "70% rule" mentioned online. It is a shortcut some house flippers use: take 70 percent of the after-repair value, then subtract repairs. It is a quick screening tool, not a law, and it is not how every buyer figures an offer. Some use a different percentage, and many, including us, prefer to list each cost line by line so you can see exactly where the money goes. The percentage version hides the details. The itemized version lets you argue with a specific number if you think it is wrong.

A simple example

These numbers are made up for illustration only. They are not a quote and they are not typical of any particular house or neighborhood.

Line itemExample amount
After-repair value, from updated nearby sales$350,000
Repairs: roof, AC, kitchen, flooring, paintminus $55,000
Buying and resale closing costs, including commissionsminus $28,000
Holding costs over the projectminus $12,000
Buyer's margin for risk and profitminus $35,000
Example cash offerabout $220,000

Looking at it this way makes the gap between "what my house could be worth" and "what a cash buyer will pay" easier to understand. Most of it is repair cost and the cost of buying, holding, and reselling. Change any one of those lines and the offer changes with it.

Why two cash offers can be so different

If you get more than one cash offer, do not be surprised if they are far apart. The most common reasons are:

  • Different comparables. One buyer starts from a higher or lower after-repair value.
  • Different repair scope. One plans a light refresh, another plans a full remodel, or one simply estimates high to leave room.
  • Different business models. A buyer who plans to keep the house as a rental may value it differently than one who plans to resell. Some companies sign a contract and then try to sell that contract to another investor, so their number has to leave room for two profits.
  • A number that is not real yet. Some buyers give a high number on the phone and lower it after an inspection period. Ask whether the offer is in writing and what could change it.

If you want help telling a solid buyer from a shaky one, we wrote a separate guide on how to tell if a cash home buyer is legit.

How to check any buyer's math

You do not need to be an investor to sanity-check an offer. Ask these questions, and expect clear answers:

  • What after-repair value did you use, and which sales did it come from?
  • What repairs did you include, and roughly what did you estimate for each?
  • Is this offer in writing? What would cause it to change before closing?
  • Are you buying it yourself, or will you assign the contract to someone else?
  • Who pays closing costs, and which title company will handle the closing?

If a repair estimate seems high, a quick quote from a licensed contractor on the big items, like the roof or AC, is a good way to test it. If the after-repair value seems low, look at what updated homes in your neighborhood have actually sold for recently, not what they were listed for.

A cash offer is not an appraisal

This is worth saying plainly. A cash offer is not an appraisal and it is not a statement of what your house is "worth." It is what one buyer is willing to pay for the house as it sits, on the timeline you need, after accounting for repairs, costs, and risk. An appraisal or a pricing opinion from an agent is a different thing for a different purpose.

That is also why a cash sale is not always the right answer. If your house is in good shape and you have time to wait for a financed buyer, listing will often put more money in your pocket, even after commissions. When that is the case, we tell you so and can connect you with our agent team, Sand + Sea Homes (eXp Realty). If you want to see both sides, ask us for a cash number and an estimated listing net side by side. Our cash offer vs. listing comparison and options for selling pages walk through how to weigh them.

Cash tends to make the most sense when the repair list is long, the deadline is real, or certainty matters more than the last dollar. That can look like an inherited house full of belongings, falling behind on payments or facing foreclosure, a divorce where both sides want a clean finish, a rental with tenant problems, or a move on a fixed date.

How we put our offers together

When you reach out, we ask about the house and what is going on, then walk the property as it sits. We pull recent sales of comparable updated homes nearby, put together a repair estimate, and add up the buying, holding, and resale costs. Then we give you a written offer and walk through the math with you, line by line, so you can see how we got there. You can push back on any number. Sometimes you know something about the house we did not, and that changes things.

There are no upfront fees and no pressure to sign on the first visit. Closing runs through a licensed Florida title company, and you pick the closing date. If the numbers do not work for you, that is a fine outcome too. You will at least know what a cash sale would look like, and you can compare it to your other options with real figures in hand. Our page on how we buy houses lays out the steps, and our FAQ covers common questions.

The bottom line

Cash buyers usually figure their offer by starting with what the house could sell for after repairs, then subtracting repairs, closing costs on both ends, holding costs, and a margin for risk and profit. Rules of thumb like the 70% rule are shortcuts, not standards. The best protection you have is a buyer who puts every line in writing and lets you check it.

If you want to see that math on your own house, request a free, no-obligation cash offer or call or text us at (941) 241-7272. You can also email Eric at eric@gchinvestors.com. We will walk through the numbers with you and tell you honestly if listing looks like the better path.

This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Example figures are for illustration only and are not an offer or a valuation of any property.

Frequently asked questions

How do cash home buyers calculate their offer?

Most cash buyers work backward. They start with what the house could sell for once it is fixed up, then subtract repairs, buying and selling costs, holding costs, and a margin for their time and risk. What is left is the most they can pay. There is no law or industry standard that sets a cash offer, so every buyer runs their own numbers.

What is after-repair value?

After-repair value (ARV) is what the house would likely sell for on the open market if it were updated and move-in ready. It is not your online estimate, what you paid, or what your neighbor listed for. It comes from recent sales of comparable updated homes nearby, adjusted for differences like square footage, bedrooms, lot, pool, and location.

Is the 70% rule how every cash buyer sets an offer?

No. The 70% rule is a shortcut some house flippers use: take 70 percent of the after-repair value, then subtract repairs. It is a quick screening tool, not a law. Some buyers use a different percentage, and many, including us, prefer to list each cost line by line so you can see where the money goes.

Is a cash offer the same as an appraisal?

No. A cash offer is not an appraisal and it is not a statement of what your house is worth. It is what one buyer is willing to pay for the house as it sits, on the timeline you need, after accounting for repairs, costs, and risk.

Whatever you're facing, let's talk it through.

Call or text a real local person. No scripts, no pressure.

Prefer to list for top dollar? List with our agent team, Sand + Sea Homes (eXp Realty) →

📞 Call (941) 241-7272