How to tell if a cash home buyer is legit
A simple checklist for verifying any buyer before you sign, including us. By Eric and Traci Bolen, November 8, 2026.
- Cash offer, no obligation
- No repairs, cleaning, or commissions
- You pick the closing date
No pressure, ever. Your info stays private.
"Is this cash buyer legit?" is a fair question, and it is one we hear from homeowners all over Sarasota, Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, North Port, and Port Charlotte. If you own a house here, you have probably gotten the postcards, the texts, and the "I'd like to buy your house" voicemails. Some come from real local buyers. Some come from people who never intend to buy anything themselves. A few are outright scams.
The good news is that checking a cash buyer does not take a law degree. Most of it takes about twenty minutes, a phone, and a few free public websites. Below is the checklist we would want our own parents to use, including how to check us. We buy houses for cash in Sarasota, Manatee, and Charlotte County, so we have a point of view, whether you want a cash offer for your North Port home or you are selling a house in Venice for cash. We still think every seller should verify every buyer, us included.
Why this matters more when you are under pressure
Most people looking at a cash offer are not doing it for fun. They are dealing with a foreclosure notice, an inherited house, a divorce, a house with repairs they cannot fund, or storm damage. When life is heavy, it is natural to want the first person who sounds confident to make the problem go away. That is exactly when a slow, careful look at the buyer pays off. A legitimate buyer will not mind. In our experience, the ones who push back on simple questions are the ones worth walking away from.
1. Confirm the company is real and the names match
Start with the basics. A real buyer has a registered business name, a phone number that reaches a person, and an address that is not just a P.O. box. In Florida you can look up any LLC or corporation for free on Sunbiz, the state Division of Corporations site. Check that the company is active, see who the officers or managers are, and note when it was formed.
Then compare. The name on the website, the name on the business card, and the name on the purchase contract should all line up. If the person you are talking to cannot explain how they are connected to the company on the paperwork, ask until you get a clear answer.
2. Ask for proof of funds, then verify it yourself
A cash buyer should be able to show they have the money. That usually means a recent bank statement or a letter from their bank or lender, in the buyer's name, showing funds at or above your price. Serious buyers keep this ready because serious sellers ask.
A document can look official and still be fake, so take one more step. Look up the bank's phone number on its own website, not the number printed on the letter, and call to confirm the letter is real. Banks usually will not share a balance, but they can often confirm whether they issued the letter.
3. Check reviews, complaints, and real closed deals
Search the company's exact name with words like "reviews," "complaints," and "scam." Look at Google reviews and the Better Business Bureau, and read how the company answered complaints, not just the rating. Ask how long they have been buying in your area and whether they can point you to past sellers you can talk to.
You can also check county records yourself. The Sarasota, Manatee, and Charlotte County property appraiser and clerk websites show recorded deeds, so you can see whether a company has actually taken title to homes locally. A company with no recorded purchases is not automatically a problem, but it is worth weighing against one with a long local history.
4. Ask the assignment question out loud
This is the one most sellers never think to ask: "Are you buying this house yourself, or do you plan to assign the contract to someone else?"
Some people who send "we buy houses" mail are wholesalers. They put your home under contract, then try to sell that contract to a different investor for a fee before closing. That is not always illegal or bad, but you deserve to know about it up front, because if they cannot find a buyer, your closing can stall or fall apart. Look for language in the contract like "and/or assigns" next to the buyer's name. If you see it, ask what it means for your deal in plain English.
We buy houses as principal investors, for our own account. We are happy to explain exactly who is buying and who will sign at closing.
5. Get the offer in writing and read every line
A verbal number on the phone is not an offer. A real offer is a written contract that shows the price, the closing date, who pays which closing costs, any inspection or due diligence period, and what happens to the earnest money if someone backs out.
Watch for a few things in particular:
- A long inspection or "due diligence" window that lets the buyer walk away for weeks with no cost to them.
- A vague closing date, or language that lets the buyer extend it again and again.
- A price that drops sharply after the walkthrough with no clear reason. Ask them to show you the repair math.
- Anyone who discourages you from having a Florida real estate attorney or a trusted family member read the contract first.
Keep in mind that a cash offer is not an appraisal. It is one buyer's price for your house as it sits, on your timeline. A legitimate buyer should be able to walk you through how they got there. You can read how we build our numbers on our FAQ and how we buy houses pages.
6. Close through a neutral title company or attorney
In a normal Florida sale, a licensed title company or real estate attorney handles the closing. The buyer's earnest money deposit is held by that neutral party, not by the buyer. The buyer's funds are wired to the title company, the deed is recorded, and the title company pays you and any lender or lien holders.
You can test this before closing day. Look up the title company's number yourself and call to ask whether they have an open file on your property with this buyer, and whether the earnest money has arrived. If the deposit was due days ago and is not there, that tells you something.
Red flags that mean slow down or walk away
- They ask you to pay anything up front: an application fee, an "appraisal" fee, a fee to stop foreclosure, or anything else before closing.
- They want to pay you, or have you pay them, outside of a title company or attorney's escrow.
- They pressure you to sign today, with "this offer expires tonight" style deadlines.
- They will not show proof of funds, or keep promising it "later."
- They ask you to sign over the deed before you are paid, or suggest a deal where they take title while your mortgage stays in your name. If you are behind on payments, be especially careful here, and see our behind on payments page and free Florida foreclosure guide for safer options.
- The story changes every time you ask how the process works.
If something feels wrong, you can report it to the Florida Attorney General's consumer protection office or the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. If a buyer claims to be a licensed real estate agent, you can check that on the Florida DBPR license lookup at myfloridalicense.com.
Questions to ask any cash buyer, including us
- What is your company's legal name, and who will sign the contract?
- Can you show me recent proof of funds in that name?
- Are you buying this house yourself, or might you assign the contract?
- Which title company or attorney will handle closing?
- How much earnest money will you deposit, and when?
- How did you arrive at this price, and what repairs did you assume?
- What happens if you find something on the walkthrough you did not expect?
- Is there any fee I will pay you, now or at closing?
When a cash buyer is not the right answer at all
Sometimes the most honest thing a buyer can tell you is that you do not need them. If your home is in good shape and you have a few months, listing on the open market may put more money in your pocket. Traci and our agent team at Sand + Sea Homes (eXp Realty) handle traditional listings, and we will be clear about which hat we are wearing. If you want both numbers, ask for a cash offer and an estimated listing net side by side. Our cash offer vs. listing comparison and options for selling pages lay out the tradeoffs.
Check us out the same way
We are Eric and Traci Bolen, a family-run local company. We buy for our own account, put every offer in writing, close at a licensed title company, and never ask sellers for upfront fees. Look us up, read our reviews, and learn more about our company. Ask us every question on the list above. We would rather earn your trust slowly than rush you.
When you are ready, request a free, no-obligation cash offer, call or text us at (941) 241-7272, or email Eric at eric@gchinvestors.com. We will listen first, and if a cash sale is not the best path for you, we will tell you.
This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. For questions about a contract, title, foreclosure, or taxes, talk with a Florida real estate attorney or tax professional.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if a cash home buyer is legit?
Checking a cash buyer takes about twenty minutes, a phone, and a few free public websites. Confirm the company is real and the names match, ask for proof of funds and verify it yourself, check reviews and complaints, ask the assignment question, get the offer in writing, and close through a neutral title company or attorney.
How do I verify a cash buyer's company in Florida?
In Florida you can look up any LLC or corporation for free on Sunbiz, the state Division of Corporations site. Check that the company is active, see who the officers or managers are, and note when it was formed. The name on the website, the business card, and the purchase contract should all line up.
What is the assignment question to ask a cash buyer?
Ask: "Are you buying this house yourself, or do you plan to assign the contract to someone else?" Some people who send "we buy houses" mail are wholesalers who put your home under contract and then try to sell that contract to a different investor for a fee. If they cannot find a buyer, your closing can stall or fall apart.
What red flags mean I should walk away from a cash buyer?
Slow down or walk away if a buyer asks you to pay anything up front, wants payment handled outside a title company or attorney's escrow, pressures you to sign today, will not show proof of funds, or asks you to sign over the deed before you are paid.
